|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 21, 2024 22:20:31 GMT
Jury selection begins in the trial of a man charged in a New York City subway chokehold death NEW YORK (AP) — Jury selection began Monday in the trial of a U.S. Marine Corps veteran charged with manslaughter for placing a man in a deadly chokehold on a New York City subway train last year. Daniel Penny, 25, is accused of “recklessly causing the death” of Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old former street performer. Witnesses say Neely was acting erratically on the train on May 1, 2023, when Penny moved to restrain him. Penny has pleaded not guilty in the case, which sparked debate and division locally and across the country. After the death of Neely, who was Black, protesters demanded that authorities arrest Penny, who is white. Others rallied in support of Penny outside the courthouse once he was charged. The case also became a cause célèbre among Republican presidential hopefuls. Penny, who served four years in the Marines before being discharged in 2021, has been free on a $100,000 bond. He faces up to 15 years in prison if convicted of second-degree manslaughter and up to four years if convicted of criminally negligent homicide. An initial group of 136 potential jurors were brought into the Manhattan courtroom Monday for a first round of screening focused on whether they have work or family obligations that could keep them from serving on a trial that’s expected to continue into December. When the first group of people were asked whether any had heard of the case, nearly everyone in the packed courtroom raised a hand to indicate yes. “Not a surprise,” Judge Maxwell Wiley said. “Even if you have formed an opinion about it, that does not disqualify you from serving on this case,” he said, adding that anyone who is picked for the jury must keep an open mind. Penny, at times when prompted by the judge, briefly stood and waved to prospective jurors and greeted them with a soft “good morning” or “good afternoon.” Otherwise, he sat mostly facing the judge in his blue suit and maroon tie as potential jurors were called up individually to the bench to explain their potential scheduling issues. Those asking not to be placed on the jury cited holiday travel plans, faraway weddings, house moves and other personal obligations. By the end of the day, some 45 people were asked to return for the next stage in the screening on Friday; the rest were excused. The selection process is expected to continue Tuesday, and it will likely be days before prospective jurors are questioned about any beliefs, personal connections or life experiences that could affect their ability to serve fairly and impartially. Witnesses to the incident said Neely — who struggled with drug addiction, mental illness and homelessness — had been shouting and demanding money when Penny approached him. Penny pinned Neely to the ground with the help of two other passengers, and placed him in a chokehold for more than three minutes until Neely’s body went limp. The medical examiner’s office ruled the death a homicide caused by compression of the neck. Neely’s father, Andre Zachery, was among those in courtroom audience Monday. The family’s lawyer, Donte Mills, said outside court that Zachery is feeling hurt and seeking justice for his son. “This is going to be a very simple case that’s easy for the jury to deliberate on,” Mills said. “The facts of the case is this: someone got on the train and was screaming, and someone choked that person to death. Those things will never balance out and there’s no justification that can make those things balance out.” Penny’s lawyers have argued that the Long Island native didn’t intend to kill Neely, just to hold him down long enough for police to arrive. Penny has claimed Neely shouted, “I’m gonna kill you” and that he was “ready to die” or go to jail for life. “We feel that the truth is only going to come out through this trial,” Steven Raiser, one of Penny’s lawyers, said outside court. “There’s a lot of evidence that people aren’t aware of. There’s a lot of assumptions that have been made that are going to be dispelled once we have all the evidence.” Raiser has said the defense plans to offer up other potential causes of Neely’s death, including high levels of the synthetic cannabinoid known as K2 found in his body. They’ll also argue that video shared widely on social media proves Penny was not applying pressure consistently enough to render Neely unconscious, much less kill him. Penny’s lawyers said Monday that they hadn’t decided whether he will testify. Prosecutors, in their court filings, have argued that Penny’s actions were reckless and negligent even if he didn’t intend to kill Neely. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office declined to comment ahead of the trial. thehill.com/homenews/ap/ap-u-s-news/ap-subway-chokehold-death-trial-jury-selection/
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 21, 2024 22:51:27 GMT
Daniel Penny trial begins over Jordan Neely subway death If convicted, Penny could face up to 19 years in prison The highly publicized trial of Daniel Penny, a former Marine charged with the choking death of Jordan Neely, an unarmed Black man, is set to begin in New York City. This case has sparked intense debate over issues of race, mental health and the limits of self-defense in a society grappling with systemic injustice. Background of the incident On May 1, 2023, Neely, a 30-year-old street performer, was reportedly experiencing a mental health crisis while riding the northbound F train in Manhattan. Eyewitnesses described Neely as agitated, shouting about his hunger and expressing a willingness to go to jail. In response, Penny, 24, intervened by placing Neely in a chokehold that lasted approximately 15 minutes, ultimately leading to Neely’s death. Initially, police did not charge Penny, which led to public outcry and demands for accountability. Following significant pressure, a grand jury indicted him on charges of second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide. If convicted, Penny could face up to 19 years in prison. The legal proceedings Jury selection for Penny’s trial commenced recently, with the court tasked with finding impartial jurors amid widespread media coverage and public opinion surrounding the case. Penny has pleaded not guilty, claiming he acted out of self-defense to protect other passengers from Neely’s perceived threats. His defense team argues that Penny’s military training informed his response to what he believed was a dangerous situation. Conversely, Neely’s family has been vocal in their calls for justice, pushing for murder charges against Penny. They argue that Neely was not a threat and that Penny’s actions were excessive and unjustified. Public reaction and protests The incident has ignited protests across New York City, with activists demanding justice for Neely and accountability for Penny. Demonstrators have gathered outside the courthouse, emphasizing the need for systemic change in how society addresses mental health crises and the treatment of marginalized individuals. Activists have also criticized the narrative surrounding Penny, with many viewing him as a vigilante who took the law into his own hands rather than a protector of public safety. The case has become emblematic of broader societal issues, including race relations and the treatment of unhoused individuals. Jordan Neely’s life and struggles Neely’s tragic death is compounded by a history of trauma. Neely’s mother was murdered by her boyfriend when he was just 14 years old, an event that deeply affected him and contributed to his struggles with mental health. Family members have stated that Neely suffered from depression and schizophrenia, conditions that went untreated due to systemic failures in mental health care. His aunt, Carolyn Neely, has spoken out about the impact of his mother’s death on his life. This context adds a layer of complexity to the narrative surrounding Neely’s actions on the subway that day. Daniel Penny’s defense and public support In the wake of the incident, Penny has received significant financial support for his legal defense, raising over $3 million through crowdfunding efforts. Supporters have labeled him a hero, arguing that he acted in self-defense. This support has been met with backlash from those who view his actions as a manifestation of systemic racism and a failure to protect vulnerable individuals. Penny has publicly stated that he did not intend to kill Neely and has denied that race played a role in his decision to intervene. His defense team continues to assert that he was merely trying to protect himself and others on the train. A case of vigilantism or self-defense? The trial of Penny raises critical questions about the nature of justice, the responsibilities of citizens in crisis situations, and the systemic issues that lead to tragic outcomes for individuals like Neely. As the trial unfolds, it will undoubtedly continue to provoke discussions about race, mental health and the societal structures that shape our responses to crisis. rollingout.com/2024/10/21/daniel-penny-trial-begins-jordan-nealy/
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 21, 2024 23:32:07 GMT
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 0:53:13 GMT
Daniel Penny trial: Jury selection underway in case surrounding subway performer Jordan Neely’s chokehold death The Daniel Penny trial officially got underway Monday as the court looked to select jurors to oversee the infamous 2023 train ride chokehold death of Jordan Neely. Penny is accused of taking Neely’s life during an incident on board a Lower Manhattan F train in May 2023. Neely’s death sparked mass protests in May after his death was caught on camera, and the footage quickly went viral on social media. Penny’s defense team alleges that Neely — who was known to dress as Michael Jackson and busk in the transit system — was threatening strangers, prompting Penny to step in and act in self-defense. While prospective jurors are being quizzed, both the prosecution and the legal defense are plotting their paths forward. Penny’s legal team told journalists that they believe their client will be found innocent despite facing second-degree manslaughter and negligent charges. The lawyers called Neely’s death a tragedy but also argued that he was under the influence of a mental health crisis and drugs that made him a potential danger to subway riders. The jury selection, which may not be fully completed until Friday, is based on various factors, including each individual’s familiarity with the case. Outside the court at 100 Centre St., protesters led by Black Lives Matter of Greater New York co-founder Hawk Newsome picketed and demanded “justice for Jordan Neely, with some demonstrators having already passed their judgment on Penny. “He [Neely] was experiencing a crisis of hunger and homelessness,” protester Christian Joseph said. “The facts in this trial for the jury are simple. The only person on that train in Manhattan that became violent was Daniel Penny. He initiated violence. Daniel Penny, an ex-US Marine soldier, jumped on Jordan Neely and put him in a chokehold that ended his life.” One of Penny’s lawyers said that they have “ample evidence” supporting their client’s claim that Neely posed a safety threat to riders which compelled Penny into action. “The paranoid schizophrenia, the psychotic episodes that he had a history of, the k2 use, and how that affects someone, particularly how it affects someone and how he intersects with someone who has that sort of psychotic condition. And of course, his behavior on the subway train — that’s what’s relevant in this case,” attorney Thomas Kenniff. “There is going to be ample evidence.” Kenniff, who was joined by fellow legal counsel Steven Raiser, said they are zeroed in on the selection process. “This is the part where we get to pick a jury of people that are going to be fair and impartial and give Danny the trial that he deserves,” Raiser said. While those in Penny’s defense claim that the Marine acted in defense of himself and other riders, the prosecution says his actions became criminal when he refused to relinquish the chokehold. Meanwhile, Neely family attorney Donte Mills — accompanied by Andre Zachery, Neely’s father — beleives that the jury will end up finding Penny culpable for his death. “This is going to be, and it is a very simple case. It’s easy for the jury to deliberate on. The fact of the case is this, someone got on the train and was screaming, and someone choked that person to death. Those things will never balance out. And there’s no justification that can make those things balance out,” Mills declared. “Zachary, Mr. Jordan’s father, when you ask him how he feels, he feels hurt.” The trial is expected to last about six weeks. www.amny.com/news/daniel-penny-trial-jury-selection-10212024/
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 1:24:12 GMT
From Gifted Performer to Tragic Loss: Jordan Neely’s Death Brings Daniel Penny to Trial A widely shared video showing a former Marine placing a man in a chokehold aboard a New York City subway train will be at the heart of the trial of Daniel Penny, who faces charges in the death of celebrated Michael Jackson performer Jordan Neely. The video, which has sparked nationwide debates on race and public safety, shows Penny restraining Neely in a chokehold until his death. Penny, 26, is charged with manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide and has pleaded not guilty. He faces a maximum of 15 years in prison if convicted of the top charge. The trial began this week and is expected to last six weeks, with the defense and prosecution planning to rely heavily on the four-minute video to make their case. Penny’s attorneys argue that he did not apply enough force for the chokehold to be fatal, while prosecutors contend that he used excessive and unjustified force against Neely, a 30-year-old Black man who had been struggling with homelessness and mental health issues. According to the New York City chief medical examiner, Neely died from compression to his neck, and the death has been ruled a homicide. The incident has become another flashpoint in discussions about racial justice, the treatment of homeless individuals, and the safety of New York’s subway system. Following Neely’s death, police initially questioned Penny and then released him without filing any charges — a move that received harsh criticism from activists and elected officials. Outside the Manhattan courthouse this week where the trial will take place, supporters of Neely continue to call for justice. In the wake of Neely’s death, those who knew him personally have shared his life story with many people. One of those voices is Moses Harper, a professional dancer who wrote a tribute to Neely for The Marshall Project titled “My Friend Jordan Neely Was Homeless and in Mental Distress. But He Was Not Expendable.” “I first met Jordan in 2009, after Michael Jackson died,” Harper wrote. “He was in Times Square performing with a couple of his friends, and I was coming out of a dance studio where I’d been teaching the ‘Thriller’ dance moves. Jordan, who was 16 at the time, was surrounded by tourists, engaging with all different types of people. He picked me out of the crowd and said, ‘Come here, let’s do this! Don’t be scared.’” Harper recalled how Neely was always full of life when performing but faced immense personal challenges. Neely’s mother was murdered when he was 14, a trauma that Harper said deeply affected him. “That kind of hurt is indescribable,” Harper wrote. “Performing as Michael Jackson was his escape.” Despite his talent, Neely struggled with mental health and homelessness in the years leading up to his death. Harper reflected on how Neely often felt invisible and ashamed of his circumstances, even as he tried to maintain his dignity through his performances. “There is too much pressure put on Black men to hold a certain type of posture and profile,” Harper wrote. “For Jordan, I’d imagine he felt like, ‘The last time you saw me, I was dressed up like the greatest entertainer in the world. Look at me now.’” Harper noted the broader systemic failures of individuals like Neely, who are often neglected by society. “The system failed Jordan,” he wrote. “He didn’t have a diploma, he was homeless, and he was dealing with mental health issues. On top of all of that, when he performed, he would get antagonized by people who hated Michael Jackson.” As the trial moves forward, the video of the fatal incident will serve as a key piece of evidence in determining whether Penny’s actions were justified. But for those who knew Neely, the trial is about more than just a legal verdict — it is about the value of a life lost too soon. “When I think of Jordan Neely, I think of a gifted, kind, young soul who was trying to find some joy and peace in this world,” Harper wrote. “He was priceless.” www.washingtoninformer.com/nyc-subway-chokehold-trial/
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 2:04:10 GMT
My Friend Jordan Neely Was Homeless and in Mental Distress. But He Was Not Expendable. Jordan Neely was choked to death on a New York City subway car. Mentor and fellow Michael Jackson enthusiast Moses Harper recalls who he was in life. On May 1, Daniel Penny, a White former Marine, choked Jordan Neely, a Black homeless man in mental distress, to death on a New York City subway car. Witnesses — including a freelance journalist who captured video of the fatal chokehold — said that Neely did not touch anyone, but was yelling that he was tired, hungry, unafraid of returning to jail, and ready to die. Penny, 24, claimed he was protecting himself and other passengers. During the minutes-long chokehold, two other men held down Neely’s arms. Within days, the city’s medical examiner ruled the death a homicide. Neely’s killing — and the nearly two weeks it took for police to arrest Penny for manslaughter — sparked condemnation and protests from residents, activists and some Democratic politicians from New York. Some called the killing a case of racist vigilantism and an example of New York City’s systemic failure to protect people with mental illness and without homes. Citing Neely’s history of violence and drug use, right-wing commentators and politicians declared Penny a hero. But there is another way to remember Jordan Neely. Before the 30-year-old became a symbol of urban crisis, he was a street performer who specialized in impersonating Michael Jackson. Here, his friend Moses Harper reflects on their first meeting, his painful life, and how he used dance to quiet his demons. I first met Jordan in 2009, after Michael Jackson died. He was in Times Square performing with a couple of his friends, and I was coming out of a dance studio where I’d been teaching the “Thriller” dance moves. Jordan, who was 16 at the time, was surrounded by tourists, engaging with all different types of people. Then he picked me out of the crowd. "Come here, let’s do this! Don’t be scared,” he said, gesturing to me. “No, I am watching. This is great,” I responded. He walked over to me. “Let’s show these people,” he said. Now, Jordan didn’t know that I am a Michael Jackson tribute artist and had performed at the Apollo Theater and Madison Square Garden. He didn’t know anything about me. But when I asked him for the hat he was wearing, I could see him slowly realize that he’d walked into a landmine. When he saw me dancing, he was astounded. From that day on, he just wanted to develop his craft. “Whatever you want to learn,” I said, “I will teach you.” Over the years, Jordan and I would meet up at different Michael Jackson events around the city. He would confide in me, and I would confide in him. I learned that he had faced a lot of trauma in his life. He was just 14 when his mother was murdered by her boyfriend, and her body was placed in a suitcase. That kind of hurt is indescribable. I don’t know about all of the ways that Jordan was trying to escape his pain, but perhaps the biggest one was performing. When he was Michael, moving his body, he could forget about his life. He was beautiful to watch. He had a gift, and I really appreciated watching him make it safe for a crowd to engage and dance. Being an artist, being a creator is how I decompress, too. I am a survivor of childhood physical and emotional abuse. And even though I have been through all these horrible things, I knew there had to be something else for my life. That’s why whenever I met up with Jordan, I’d also encourage him to get his business in order. He didn’t have a high school diploma. I’d tell him that he needed to get an education. It is hard enough growing up as a Black man in the city. But with no education, and everything he had faced, he was particularly vulnerable. I know how hard that path can be. For years, I have done outreach with vulnerable populations — homeless people, LGBTQ youth and young men charged with violent felonies at Rikers Island. I’ve also visited food pantries and homeless shelters. In every borough, in every shelter I’ve been to, the feedback is the same: People don’t feel safe or cared for. They don’t feel seen. Because these are the unwanted — the homeless, the untouchables — no one will check to make sure that the people responsible for providing them resources are doing their jobs. The most difficult experience I had was working in Rikers Island for several years. Inside, you are surrounded by trauma — people in cages yelling and fighting, aromas of bodily waste. It was hard to hear men cry in conversation because no one had ever spoken to them like they mattered. And some of the young homeless men I met at Rikers told me about the advice they’d gotten from elders: When the weather gets cold, if you can’t get into a shelter or get a meal, commit a public disturbance or a low-level crime. Why? Because of various disorderly conduct and curfew laws, you can’t sleep on a park bench at night or on the train, even when it’s cold outside. But if you can get locked up, you can get a bed and a warm meal. If you express suicidal ideations, they’ll take you to a hospital, and you’ll have a place to stay. There are supposed to be resources in place so that people don’t have to resort to these desperate means. But the system is so broken. When I would lose track of Jordan, it was scary. Our community of people who loved Michael Jackson would look for him online, scouring social media posts until he popped up. “Did you hear from him?” we’d text each other. “Yeah, I saw him. He’s good.” One time I caught Jordan in the subway. It broke my heart to see how ashamed he was of his situation. He wouldn’t accept help from the people who loved him. There is too much pressure put on Black men to hold a certain type of posture and profile. For Jordan, I’d imagine he felt like, The last time you saw me, I was dressed up like the greatest entertainer in the world. Look at me now. The last time I saw Jordan, he tried to walk past me, but I wouldn’t let him. I gave him a big hug. “No, you are coming with me,” I said. I bought him food and gave him money. “When you are ready to get clean and clean up, I got you,” I told him.“Don’t worry, I am going to do it,” he replied. But the system failed Jordan. He was traumatized. He didn’t have a diploma. He had to face the stress of being out on the street and being treated like he was invisible. On top of all of that, when he performed, he would get antagonized by people who hated Michael Jackson. They would call him a child molester. One of the things I tried to instill in Jordan is that you can’t react. But it’s hard to do that. You’re not supposed to defend yourself when some stranger who doesn’t know your heart or your struggles is trying to antagonize you? When the news of his killing broke, I was in a school in the Bronx. I got the message from a friend in the M.J. community who lives in Florida. “I want you to see this,” she texted. “Moses, I think you need to look at this.”It took a matter of minutes for Daniel Penny to become Jordan’s arresting officer, judge, clerk, D.A., jury and executioner. But I don’t care what my friend’s arrest record was. I don’t care if he was homeless. He wasn’t hurting anyone, and if you support Penny’s actions, you don’t support due process. Daniel Penny probably figured that no one would even come looking for this homeless guy. That no one would care. But when I think of Jordan Neely, I think of a gifted, kind, young soul who was trying to find some joy and peace in this world. He was looking for a reason to celebrate and engage in something positive. And it is painful to think that somebody treated him like he wasn’t worth anything. He was priceless. www.themarshallproject.org/2023/05/26/daniel-penny-deadly-chokehold-on-jordan-neely?gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQjw99e4BhDiARIsAISE7P-ijIFt6H9OPUR1l8UzCXNPwiyRDVrT6NQrxsqvdPmOq5avv6t9y_waAjjeEALw_wcB
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 12:15:12 GMT
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 18:05:07 GMT
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 22, 2024 21:26:06 GMT
LIVE: Outside court as jury selection begins in Daniel Penny's trial in New York
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 23, 2024 5:27:30 GMT
Daniel Penny’s defense likely to invoke NYC subway as a key ‘witness’ in fatal chokehold trial Over the next several weeks, a Manhattan jury will decide whether a 26-year-old former Marine should go to prison for putting another man in a fatal chokehold on the subway and continuing to squeeze his neck for about six minutes. Daniel Penny stands trial this month on charges of manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the death of Jordan Neely, a homeless man who witnesses say was yelling that he was hungry and ready to go to prison while aboard an uptown F train in May 2023. The Manhattan district attorney’s office says Penny should have known the chokehold could put Neely’s life in danger. Penny’s attorneys say he was trying to help subway commuters who felt unsafe, and that he didn’t mean to hurt or kill anyone. A video that shows several minutes of the chokehold and its aftermath went viral after Neely’s death and underscored deep fissures in the debate about homelessness, mental illness and safety on the subway. Some called Penny a hero and donated to a multimillion-dollar legal defense fund, while others characterized him as an overzealous vigilante. As Penny’s trial gets underway this month, legal experts say, prosecutors will likely try to convince jurors that his individual actions over a handful of minutes caused Neely’s death — and that he went beyond what a reasonable person would do. Penny’s attorneys, on the other hand, will have to convince jurors that his actions were warranted. To do that, experts expect one key witness to play a starring role in Penny’s case: New York City’s public transit system. Fear about subway crime has persisted in the transit system in recent years, especially after ridership decreased during the pandemic. A handful of high-profile acts of violence by people with severe mental illness on subway platforms and in train cars have also stoked concerns — even though researchers have found that it’s uncommon for people with serious mental illness to commit violent crimes. Legal observers say jurors’ perception of subway safety will likely be a key factor in the case. Jurors will have to determine whether it’s reasonable for commuters like Penny to take matters into their own hands when they feel unsafe on the country’s largest subway system. “The subway is a microcosm of all of this,” said Todd Spodek, a defense attorney not connected to the case. “You’re not in a large area where you could just walk away. You’re stuck.“ The Manhattan DA’s office declined to comment on their legal strategy for trial. One of Penny’s attorneys, Steve Raiser, said in a text message that their case will focus on the government’s failure to address mental health and homelessness on the subway. “The [g]overnment failed Mr. Neely and every rider on that train,” he said. The prosecution: zooming in on Penny’s decisions There’s still a lot we don’t know about the moments that led to Neely’s death. But according to court papers, Neely got on an uptown F train at 2nd Avenue on the Lower East Side, threw his jacket, and yelled. Witness accounts to the grand jury varied, but multiple people on the subway that day said Neely expressed that he was hungry and thirsty. Some said Neely yelled about being ready to die or go to jail for life if he didn’t get what he wanted. Then Penny wrapped his arm around Neely’s neck, the defendant later told police. While prosecutors wouldn’t comment ahead of trial, their arguments in court records have zeroed in on the minutes and seconds that passed after Penny decided to put Neely in a chokehold on the train. They say Penny kept restraining Neely after the subway pulled into the Broadway-Lafayette station and passengers were able to leave the car, after Neely stopped moving, and after another passenger warned that Penny might kill Neely if he didn’t let go. Legal experts and court papers suggest that prosecutors will likely focus on whether Penny knew he was endangering Neely’s life as he continued to squeeze the man’s neck. Spodek said he expects the DA’s office to question Penny’s “minute by minute, second by second” decision-making process. “They're going to try and tailor their theory of the case to the immediate circumstances. That what's happening in the larger New York City area is irrelevant,” the attorney said. “The only thing that matters is what happened when they got on that train that very moment and nothing more.” Vinoo Varghese, a former Brooklyn prosecutor who now works in criminal defense, said he expects the DA’s office to also highlight Penny’s experience in the Marines. “He kept holding onto this guy, and he’s a trained military guy,” Varghese said prosecutors will likely tell the jury. “He’s not your ordinary citizen, and so he should have known that he was going to kill this guy.” The defense: tapping into jurors’ fears of subway crime Penny’s defense attorneys, Spodek and Varghese both said, will likely focus more broadly on the day-to-day environment on New York City subways that could have influenced Penny’s decision to put Neely in a chokehold. In a motion to dismiss the case filed last year, Penny’s attorneys described an atmosphere of “traumatizing” fear on the subway car after Neely boarded. They quoted passengers who said Neely’s behavior was “insanely threatening” and “satanic,” that he shouted “someone is going to die today” and that he was “ready to go to Rikers.” They cited one long-time subway commuter’s statement to the grand jury that she had encountered many things on the train, “but nothing that put fear in me like that.” Spodek said the jurors will have to ask themselves whether Penny reasonably believed that people on the F train were in danger. “Was this unique? Was the circumstances to such a high level that he had no choice but to do this?” he said. “And I think the answer is, from the defense's point of view, absolutely. And there are witness observations to support that.” Varghese said he expects Penny’s defense attorneys to try to pick jurors who can empathize with Penny and other riders who were scared on the subway that day. He said it could be more challenging to find those jurors in a largely Democratic borough. “Amongst New Yorkers on this kind of political issue, in a city that leans overwhelmingly left and blue — particularly in Manhattan — it's going to be difficult for him,” Varghese said. “But,” he added, “I think people are fed up with what they have to deal with on the subway.” ‘What do I do?’ Another central facet of the case is Neely’s psychiatric history. He was diagnosed with schizophrenia and used synthetic cannabinoids — also known as K-2 — according to court records. Experts and court filings show that information is likely to come up at trial as defense attorneys try to convince jurors that Neely was scaring subway riders. Neely’s death fueled debates about the city’s treatment of people with serious mental illness, particularly in the subway system. Mental health advocates told Gothamist they worry the trial will inflame rhetoric about subway crime and bolster misconceptions about mental illness and violence. “It will perpetuate this stigmatization of people with mental illness,” said Melissa Beck, who has worked as both a prosecutor and defense attorney and now advocates for mental health reform. “It will perpetuate the status quo of criminalizing people with mental illness, and it will do nothing to increase access to culturally competent, evidence-based care for people with mental illness.” On a recent evening at the Broadway-Lafayette station, lifelong New Yorker Nadya Belov said she’s not sure what she would decide if she were a juror in Penny’s case. “I would have to really look at the evidence,” she said, “because I wasn't there. I don't know what happened.” Belov said her first instinct is to help when she sees people in distress in the subway system, but she’s often not sure how she can. And a lot of the time, she said, she feels scared. “Sometimes people are screaming,” she said. “I've seen a guy throw stuff. And then you're in the car as it's moving and someone is throwing something, and then at that point you no longer know what the person will do. So, you're like, ‘What do I do?’ Like, I don't want to be in the middle of this if something goes down.” Belov said when something like that happens, she normally switches cars at the next stop. So does Alve Al, a friend of Neely’s who was sitting on a bench at the Broadway-Lafayette station last week. He said there was “no need” for Penny to choke Neely. “I would have walked away,” he said. “Life is more worth living. But for him to do what he did, he's going to have to pay the price.” gothamist.com/news/daniel-pennys-defense-likely-to-invoke-nyc-subway-as-a-key-witness-in-fatal-chokehold-trial
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 23, 2024 6:09:09 GMT
Protesters Demand Justice for Jordan Neely as Daniel Penny Murder Trial Begins ‘Daniel Penny killed Jordan Neely, not in self-defense, but rather in an arrogant flex of muscles to kill a nuisance,’ said one of the speakers outside the New York Criminal Court. On May 1, 2023, Jordan Neely, a beloved street performer, boarded a northbound F train at the Second Avenue subway station. After the train doors closed, Neely cried out to his fellow passengers, expressing that he had neither food nor water. In Neely’s moment of distress, ex-Marine Daniel Penny jumped on Neely and put him in a chokehold, killing him. Penny walked home scot-free that night. In the days following Neely’s murder, people took to the streets and subways in protest and rage, calling for the arrest of Penny and justice for Neely, who before being murdered by Penny, was made vulnerable and left without adequate support from the City of New York as he experienced homelessness and mental health issues. Penny is now standing trial for his murder of Neely, who was best known for his Michael jackson imitations, and on Oct. 21, as jury selection for the trial commenced at the New York City Criminal Court, the New York City-based December 12th Movement (D12M) held a press conference to reiterate the demand that Penny be held accountable. “The facts are simple for the jury. Available video confirms that Jordan Neely did not initiate violence to anyone on that train,” Christian Joseph of D12M said at the press conference. “Daniel Penny chose to use the moment of a poor Black man’s call for help to act out his racist underlying tendencies. … Daniel Penny killed Jordan Neely, not in self-defense, but rather in an arrogant flex of muscles to kill a nuisance.” Penny is being charged with second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide, both of which he has pleaded not guilty to. A second-degree manslaughter conviction carries a minimum sentence of three years and a maximum of 15. Penny wasn’t charged until more than a week after he had killed Neely. Prosecutors have been criticized for obscuring and undermining the intentional racist violence Penny unleashed upon Neely. “Daniel Penny is a civilian, an ex-Marine, who is trained to kill people. … He knew what he was doing,” said Roger Wareham, attorney and International Secretariat of D12M. “Given what he was, given who he is, the penalty should be higher. And the signal that’s being sent to the vigilantes [is], you can get away with this if it’s a Black life. It really doesn’t matter.” Imani Henry, a member of Equality for Flatbush and a social worker for over 25 years, spoke about the city’s systematic divestment from social services and investment instead into the NYPD — a process of organized abandonment that only leaves working-class New Yorkers of color like Neely at more risk of organized violence. “The bigger issue of this is that the city of New York spends more money on the NYPD than making sure that our people have housing,” Henry said. “We need money for housing and services. Not more cops, not more police violence, not shootings on the train and definitely not to create an energy and climate that is about vigilantism, is about racism, is about white supremacy and about demonizing and criminalizing people who are just trying to live and survive in New York City under this gentrification that is ethnically cleansing our neighborhoods.” Following the press conference, the crowd of over 50 rallied for an hour, carrying signs reading “Justice for Jordan Neely: End Racist Vigilantism Now!” and “Rest in Power Jordan Neely #AbolishThePolice” and ringing out the chant of “Justice for who? Jordan Neely!” outside the 100 Centre St. courthouse. Omowale Clay of the D12M echoed the words of other members who expressed that the call for the press conference and rally was to both re-engage people’s consciousness and to call people back into action. “The brother was murdered on the train,” Clay said. “It’s not that long ago, if you remember Sutter Avenue, when the police opened up on a crowded platform over $2.90. We’re not gonna be intimidated. We’re not gonna be run out of New York City. We got a cop in City Hall. We got cops everywhere. And there’s no justice anywhere for poor, Black and people of color. So we want folks to know that we are not going anywhere.” indypendent.org/2024/10/protesters-demand-justice-for-jordan-neely-as-daniel-penny-murder-trial-begins/
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 23, 2024 20:08:09 GMT
Daniel Penny Greeted By Protesters As Jury Selection Continues: 'Murderer!' Protesters called Daniel Penny a "murderer" as jury selection continues in the high-profile New York City chokehold case. Penny, a 25-year-old former Marine, is accused of killing 30-year-old Jordan Neely on a subway in 2023. Neely, who was a well-known Michael Jackson impersonator, boarded the subway and reportedly began yelling and threatening people. Penny allegedly approached him from behind and placed him in the restraint. Neely was taken to a hospital, where he was pronounced dead. His death was ruled a homicide by compression of the neck. Penny is facing second-degree manslaughter and negligent homicide charges. Jury selection entered its second day on Tuesday. Protesters gathered outside of the courtroom holding signs reading "Rest in Power Jordan Neely." A pool of 86 jurors was brought into the courtroom on Monday. Most jurors raised their hand when asked if they had heard about the case. "Even if you have formed an opinion about it, that does not disqualify you from serving on this case," New York Supreme Court Justice Maxwell Wiley told jurors. "If you have formed an opinion on this case, you have to be prepared to change it." Wiley also asked jurors if they were able to serve in a trial expected to last up to six weeks. By midday, 58 jurors had been excused. The remaining 28 were told to return on Friday for juror questioning. A new pool of jurors was brought in during the afternoon. In that group, 17 were told to return Friday and 35 were excused. Earlier this month, Wiley ruled denied motions from both prosecutors and defense to suppress evidence during the trial. Prosecutors objected to the defense's request to enter Neely's medical records and allow certain witnesses to testify. The defense objected to prosecutors presenting statements made by Penny after the deadly incident to police at the subway station and the precinct from the trial. Wiley denied motions from both sides, clearing the way for all evidence to be presented during the trial. Use of force experts previously spoke to Newsweek about how prosecutors and defense could present their arguments. Dr. John R. Black, a retired police lieutenant and expert witness in cases involving high-stress decision making and lethal force, said prosecutors will likely focus on the severity of the threat Neely posed and the intensity of Penny's response. "The prosecutor's argument is primarily an argument of, we'll call it, disproportionate response. This person did not represent the level of threat by which the technique that the other person chose was applied, so there's a mismatch," Black said. Jamie Borden, a police veteran and expert witness in cases involving use of force, said the prosecution will likely emphasize the appearance of the incident. "The prosecution is more than likely building their case on a passionate belief that something was done wrong," Borden said. "That doesn't mean that it wasn't done wrong, but I'm saying that they'll present their case from a point of passionate belief about the appearance of the incident." The defense will likely challenge that point, according to Black. "The other argument is we have the right to use a proportional level of force, and actually the law would say a reasonably necessary level of force to protect ourselves or to protect another," Black said. Penny is facing five to 15 years in prison for the manslaughter charge and up to four years for the negligent homicide charge. www.newsweek.com/daniel-penny-trial-jordan-neely-chokehold-nyc-subway-death-1973100
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 25, 2024 20:39:04 GMT
Witnesses in Daniel Penny’s trial shouldn’t call him a ‘good Samaritan,’ prosecutors say Prosecutors are asking a Manhattan judge not to let trial witnesses call the former Marine accused of choking a homeless man on the subway a “hero” or “good Samaritan,” according to an email exchange between lawyers this week. The emails between prosecutors and Daniel Penny’s defense lawyers came as jury selection is underway in the case. Penny, a 26-year-old Long Island native, is charged in the death of Jordan Neely, a homeless man with schizophrenia who witnesses say boarded an uptown F train and started yelling that he was willing to die or go to prison for life. Penny has pleaded not guilty to manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide charges. A video that captured Penny holding Neely in a chokehold for several minutes went viral and highlighted stark divisions in the debate about subway safety. Some watched the clip in horror and accused Penny of vigilantism, while others praised him and donated nearly $3 million to a legal defense fund. Penny has said he didn’t mean to kill anyone and that he put Neely in a chokehold to subdue him, because other passengers were scared. Prosecutors argue that he acted recklessly and should have been more careful with Neely’s life. Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran raised concerns about how witnesses can refer to Penny after watching an interview Penny’s attorneys conducted on FOX5, in which they praised their client’s actions on the subway. “Danny doesn’t have to be a hero,” defense attorney Thomas Kenniff told FOX5. “But he’s someone who did the right thing. He’s someone who stood up for his fellow man, for his fellow New Yorkers.” Yoran said the DA’s office was worried that the defense attorneys might try to get witnesses to assess whether Penny’s actions on the subway were appropriate. Yoran mentioned the terms “good Samaritan” and “hero” as labels that witnesses shouldn’t be allowed to use to describe Penny, because she said they’re subjective opinions. “A witness's characterization of the defendant [as] a hero, for example, is the equivalent of a determination that the [defendant] was justified,” she wrote. Yoran said it should be up to the jury to decide whether Penny was justified — not the witnesses called to testify about the facts. But Kenniff responded that the witnesses on the subway that day are the ones who used those words “minutes after this incident” and that their characterizations of what happened should be heard in court. “It describes what they perceived, Neely acting as the aggressor, and Mr. Penny acting to defend and protect,” he wrote. A spokesperson for the Manhattan DA’s office declined to comment on the email exchange. Penny’s attorneys did not respond to an inquiry. gothamist.com/news/witnesses-in-daniel-pennys-trial-shouldnt-call-him-a-good-samaritan-prosecutors-say
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 25, 2024 21:10:03 GMT
New Details Emerge About Jurors In Daniel Penny's Deadly Chokehold Trial The judge presiding over the trial of Daniel Penny ruled that the jury will remain anonymous due to "threats" made to the prosecution and defense, as jury selection continues in the case. Penny, a 25-year-old former Marine, is accused of choking and killing 30-year-old Jordan Neely on a subway in 2023. Neely was a well-known Michael Jackson impersonator who was homeless. He boarded the subway and reportedly began threatening people. Penny allegedly approached him from behind and placed him in a chokehold. Neely was later pronounced dead at a hospital. His death was ruled a homicide by compression of the neck. Penny is charged with second-degree manslaughter and negligent homicide. Jury selection in the case began on Monday. Protestors gathered outside the courthouse held signs in support of Neely and chanted "murderer" at Penny. On Thursday, New York Supreme Court Justice Maxwell Wiley ruled in favor of the prosecution's request to conceal the identities of the 12 jurors who will be selected to hear the case. Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran made the request "based on prior threats that have been received in this case by all sides." She added that anonymity could help ensure a "fairer" outcome in the case. "I believe that's wise," Wiley said. He said he is aware of the various threats that have been made over the past several months. "There's not just opinions, but very, very strong opinions," Wiley said. "There's been people who have not been afraid to make threats." Penny's attorney, Thomas Kenniff, did not object to the request. Potential jurors are being asked if they could serve on a trial that is expected to last about six weeks. "Even if you have formed an opinion about it, that does not disqualify you from serving on this case," Wiley told potential jurors. "If you have formed an opinion on this case, you have to be prepared to change it." Individuals who are not excused are being asked to return on Friday for the next phase of juror questioning. Wiley previously said he hopes to have 90 potential jurors in court Friday. Earlier this month, Wiley ruled against motions from prosecutors and defense to suppress evidence in the trial. Prosecutors objected to the defense's request to admit Neely's medical records into evidence and allow certain witnesses to testify. The defense objected to prosecutors presenting statements made by Penny to police at the subway station and the precinct. Wiley denied motions from both sides, clearing the way for all evidence to be presented during the trial. If convicted, Penny is facing five to 15 years in prison for the manslaughter charge and up to four years for the negligent homicide charge. Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com www.newsweek.com/daniel-penny-trial-jury-selection-update-1974593
|
|
|
Post by NatureCriminal7896 on Oct 25, 2024 21:41:04 GMT
Potential jurors are questioned in the trial of a man who used a chokehold on a subway panhandler NEW YORK (AP) — Potential jurors in the trial of a white U.S. Marine Corps veteran charged with killing a troubled Black man on a subway train began answering questions about their backgrounds — including their own experiences on New York's subways. No one has yet been chosen for what will be an anonymous Manhattan jury in the manslaughter case against Daniel Penny. After days of pre-screening to excuse people who couldn't serve because of work or family duties, questioning meant to get at any potential biases or conflicts of interest has only just begun. The queries include standard biographical details, such as prospective jurors' neighborhood and line of work, but also about whether they or anyone close to them has been in the military, has experience in martial arts or wrestling, or has dealt with drug addiction or homelessness. People also are being asked how often they use the subway and whether they’ve witnessed any outbursts there. One potential juror said she takes the subway daily and has seen people act up but never felt personally harassed. Another said he hasn't ridden the nation's largest subway system since the 1980s — “I take the bus” — and recalled a fellow straphanger once trying to take his jacket, but the incident was “very minor.” Penny put Jordan Neely, 30, in a chokehold that, medical examiners said, killed him. Prosecutors say Penny's move was reckless and unwarranted. His lawyers have said he was just trying to subdue Neely, who was behaving erratically and making remarks that Penny, 25, and some witnesses recalled as threatening. The case has become a crucible for opinions about public safety, mental illness, the line between intervening and vigilantism, and the role of race in how people perceive all of it. Some demonstrators have rallied to decry Penny, others to defend him. Some prominent Democratic officials went to Neely's funeral, while high-profile Republican politicians portrayed Penny as a hero who confronted Neely to protect others. Penny's legal defense fund has raised millions of dollars. Neely, 30, had once been familiar to some subway riders for his Michael Jackson impersonations. But relatives have said he struggled with mental health problems after his mother was killed and was found stuffed in a suitcase in 2007, and he testified at her boyfriend’s murder trial five years later. Over the years, Neely became homeless and developed a history of drug use, disruptive behavior and arrests, including a guilty plea to assaulting a stranger in 2021. On May 1, 2023, Neely boarded a subway and began shouting and acting erratically, witnesses said. Some would later tell police, in comments recorded on officers' body cameras, that riders were frightened when he made sudden movements and statements about being willing to die or go to jail. But at least one passenger described Neely's behavior as "like another day, typically, in New York,” prosecutors said in a court filing. Penny, for his part, told officers that Neely said, “I’m going to kill everybody," according to police video played in court. Concerned that Neely presented an actual threat, Penny said, he approached the man from behind and put an arm around his neck and throat. With two other riders helping to pin Neely to the floor, the Marine veteran held him around the neck for more than three minutes, until his body went limp. “I put him out,” Penny told an officer at the scene. He later told detectives in an interview that he was “just trying to de-escalate,” not to injure or kill Neely. City medical examiners determined that Neely died from compression of the neck. Neely's family and supporters have said he was only appealing for help, not menacing anyone. Donte Mills, a lawyer for Neely’s father, has summed up the case this way: “Someone got on the train and was screaming, and someone choked that person to death.” “Those things will never balance out, and there’s no justification that can make those things balance out,” Mills said outside court Monday. Penny's lawyers have indicated they plan to argue that Penny wasn't applying pressure in a way that could have killed Neely, and that his death could have been caused by other factors, including the use of the synthetic cannabinoid known as K2. When the first group of potential jurors came into court Monday for pre-screening, nearly all raised hands when asked whether they'd heard of the case. “Even if you have formed an opinion about it, that does not disqualify you from serving on this case,” Judge Maxwell Wiley told them, but he reminded them that jurors must be open to the possibility that the evidence will change their views. It’s unclear how long it will take to select the jurors, whose names will not be released to the public. www.myjournalcourier.com/news/article/potential-jurors-questioned-in-trial-of-man-who-19863259.php
|
|